|
Real
costs for everyone
Gambling costs more
than raising taxes, even for those who NEVER gamble! Each compulsive
gambler costs the economy between $14,006 and $22,077 per year.[i]
If 2% become addicted, that’s $280 to $440 per year paid by every other
citizen!
Trading jobs kills development
Most casinos attract
80% or more of their market from a 35-50 mile radius. Casinos absorb
existing entertainment, restaurant and hotel business, and deplete dollars
available to other retail businesses. That destroys other jobs in the
trade area and eliminates their sales, employment and property tax
contributions.[ii]
Illegal gambling remains
Legalizing gambling
does not reduce illegal gambling.[iii]
Legalized gambling may even increase illegal gambling because untaxed
illegal operators may offer better odds, bigger payoffs and loans that
legal operations cannot. Patrons in gambling states feel gambling is
generally legal and they are less averse to gambling in unlicensed
establishments. Law enforcement in gambling states see illegal gambling as
a state revenue issue rather than a criminal activity, and may be less
motivated to investigate.
Gambling brings addiction
When gambling appears
in a community, it brings a wave of addiction. In a mature gambling
market, compulsive gambling typically seizes the lives of 1.5% to 2.5% of
the adult population. That amounts to three to five times the number of
people suffering from cancer.
“Gambling is an addictive behavior, make no mistake about it . . .
Gambling has all the properties of a psychoactive substance, and again,
the reason is that it changes the neurochemistry of the brain.”[iv]
The American Psychiatric Association says between 1% and 3% of the U.S.
population is addicted to gambling, depending on location and
demographics.[v]
Youth have even higher addiction rates, between 4 an 8%.
[vi]
Proximity and poverty matter
Addiction rates double
within 50 miles of a casino.[vii]
Probable pathological gambling in Nevada in 2000 measured 3.5%. Other
states ranged from 2.1% in North Dakota in 2000 to 4.9% in Mississippi in
1996.[viii]
A casino within 10 miles of a home yields a 90% increased risk of its
occupants becoming pathological or problem gamblers. Neighborhood
disadvantage increases that risk another 69%.[ix]
Slots and other gambling machines push susceptible players to the
pathological level in an average of 1.08 years, vs. 3.58 years with more
“conventional” forms of table and racetrack gambling.[x]
Gambling doubles bankruptcy.
It takes three to five
years for gamblers in a newly opened market to exhaust their resources.
When addiction ripens in the market, so do the social costs.
The most recent study of all the casino counties in the nation confirmed
personal bankruptcy rates are 100% higher in counties with casinos than in
counties without casinos.[xi]
Gambling increases crime
Desperate to “chase”
and recover gambling losses, pathological gamblers often turn to crime.
Fraud and embezzlement become common among formerly hard-working and
highly trusted people. Violent crimes also increase. Three years after the
introduction of casinos in Atlantic City, there was a tripling of total
crimes. Per capita crime there jumped from 50th in the nation to first.[xii]
Comparing crime rates for murder, rape, robbery, aggravated assault,
burglary and motor vehicle theft reveals Nevada is the most dangerous
place to live in the United States.[xiii]
Expect suicides.
A study of addicted gamblers revealed, “Between 20% and 30% of the
respondents made actual suicide attempts. No other addictive population
has had as high a prevalence for attempts.”[xiv]
Nevada has been the highest in the nation for suicides for 10 of the last
12 years.[xv]
[i]
Grinols, Earl L., “Cutting the Cards and Craps, right
thinking about gambling economics.” P. 14.
[ii]
Grinols, Earl L. Gambling in America, Costs and
Benefits, p.p. 55-92.
[iii]
Abt, Vickie, Ph.D., Univ. Penn.
Cited in
Executive Summary, Casinos in Florida: An analysis of the Economic and
Social Impacts, for the Florida Office of Planning and Budgeting
[iv]
Shaffer, Howard, Harvard University addictions
department, quoted by Kindt in Managerial and Decision Economics, 22:
p. 17-63
[v]
American Psychiatric Association, DSM-IV, P.673.
[vi]
Shaffer, H.J. & Hall, M.N. (1996). Estimating prevalence of adolescent
gambling disorders: A quantitative synthesis and guide toward standard
gambling nomenclature. Journal of Gambling Studies, 12,
193–214.
[vii]
National Gambling Impact Study Commission, “Final
Report” Sec. 4, p..5.
[viii]
Volberg, Rachel A., Ph.D. “Gambling and Problem
Gambling in Nevada: Report to the Nev. Depart. of Human Resources,”
p. iii.
[ix]
Welte, John W.; Wieczorek, William F.; Barnes, Grace
M.; Hoffman, Joseph H. Reference cited in “The Relationship of
Ecological and Geographic Factors to Gambling Behavior and Pathology”
p.15
[x]
Breen, Robert B. and Zimmerman, Mark; “Rapid Onset of
Pathological Gambling in Machine Gamblers” p.2
[xi]
Gross, Ernie and Morse, Edward. “The Impact of Casio
Gambling on Bankruptcy Rates: A County Level Analysis.) p. 1
[xii]
Schwer, R. Keith; Thompson, William N.; Nakamuro,
Daryl; “Beyond the Limits of Recreation: Social Costs of Gambling in
Southern Nevada.” p. 4
[xiv]
Widgery, Robin, President of Social Systems. “Warning:
Legal Gambling is a Costly Game.” 1994 edition.
|